A Verdict Has Been Announced for the Tata Consultancy Case

Ritu Jha-

U.S. District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers denied the motion for a new trial in the Tata Consultancy case, filed by former Tata workers at the Northern District Court of California this past Tuesday, Aug.13.

In November 2018, following a twelve-day trial, a jury of nine rendered a unanimous verdict in favor of the TCS but Christopher Slaight, Seyed Amir Masoudi, and Nobel Mandili, on behalf of themselves and on behalf of others similarly situated, were not convinced with the court verdict.

The former TCS employees claimed disparate treatment when employed by TCS and alleged all individuals who are not of South Asian race or Indian national origin, who were employed by TCS in the United States, were subject to a policy or practice of benching and allocation and were placed in an unallocated status which ended in termination between April 14, 2011, and December 27, 2017.

Plaintiffs’ theory of discrimination relied on their contention that TCS intentionally displaced class members by assigning Indian or South Asian employees to jobs that class members were successfully filling or could have filled, resulting in class members’ terminations from the bench.

Judge Rogers said the workers lost the case not because of an unfair jury or improper evidentiary rulings but because of their expert witness, labor economist David Neumark, who told the jury his data analysis excluded certain employees and thus failed to address the company’s primary defense.

The plaintiffs in the case say that the cross-examination significantly undermined Dr. Neumark’s credibility and his conclusions. This is especially poignant in a case such as this, where the analysis underlying Dr. Neumark’s opinion does not lend itself to an independent evaluation by the jury. Second, shortly thereafter, Dr. Neumark said that he limited the data in his analysis to TCS employees who were merely coded as “unallocated” in TCS’s system and therefore did not consider or account for why the employees whose data was analyzed had become “unallocated.”

Reasonable jurors could easily infer that Dr. Neumark’s statistical analysis chose to ignore the defendant’s primary explanations for the results, namely an employee’s unwillingness to relocate and the lack of suitable qualifications. Finally, several of TCS’s witnesses testified that Dr. Neumark’s U.S. termination rate analysis and the resulting disparities between “local attrition” and “expat attrition” did not reflect an accurate comparison. Specifically, they testified that there is almost no such thing as “expat attrition” in TCS’s U.S. workforce (except in the most extreme circumstances, such as imprisonment or death) because expats’ deputation agreements “prevent them from being terminated in the U.S.”

Judge Rogers believes that the jury paid close attention to the case.

The jury deliberated over two days before rendering a unanimous verdict in favor of TCS. The Court observed during the trial that the jurors worked very hard throughout the trial to determine how to resolve the parties’ factual disputes. They paid close attention to the exhibit screens and the witnesses; many took extensive notes; jurors posed dozens of questions during the trial and the jury deliberated for approximately eight hours.



Related posts


12BET is definitely a isolated gaming product, focused mainly on presenting sporting events playing goods and services to a
particular Western and Asian countries Pacific markets.

12BET product is handled by Pacific Sea Invests S.A., a English Virgin Isles small business
with businesses through the Cagayan Monetary Zone,
Philippines. PSI’s services and products are regulated and licensed by First Cagayan Resort and Leisure Group
(www.firstcagayan.com) for those Cagayan Fiscal Region Expert in the Philippine united states government.
A duplicate of PSI’s Philippine certification may be

Fun88 could be the leading gambling online provider in Asian countries that delivers range of fun and
exciting gaming solutions from Sportsbook, in-participate in sporting events wagering, live gambling, port game titles,
lotto solutions plus much more! To offer you our members the most current on-line playing technology and
the very best video games knowledge, Fun88 cooperates with variety of prominent
video games platform that features One Performs,Entwine and Microgaming,
Crown Gambling, Golden Betsoft, Laxino, Deluxe and PlayTech and
Bodog. We provide you with about 10,000 several Sports activities online games each and every month and
globally competitions in Fun88’s Sportsbook, even though a complete in excess of 100 on line casino activities from various baccarat, other, slots and roulette gambling house activities might be played in Fun88 Gambling


Getting governed and certified by legitimate
gambling body systems in previously ensures all associates that
play and join with FUN88 conforms to principles range of regulatory in online safe, stable and gambling platform for current
and long term members’ video games joy.

Fun88 also cooperates while using world’s very best group security
and audit strategy IOVATION, to ensure the safety and privacy within your account and information secrecy.


Within the duration of five years in the business, Fun88 was
given nominations by EGR Honors well organized by eGaming Review
Mag the “Asian Are living Gambling Owner of year”, “Oriental User of year Nominations for 2009” and “Oriental Owner Nominations for 2010”

In 2014, Fun88 works with Lamborghini making Fun88 Race to remain competitive in GT Asia Championship.
For the present, it sponsors Fun88 Competition to compete
in Porsche Carrera Glass.

Fun88 is usually found in the MMA field, partnering with Asia’s most significant sporting events mass media house, An individual Championship, in 2015.

Its brand ambassadors include things like nfl football tale Robbie NBA and Fowler two-time MVP Steve
Nash. Experiencing such big brands in sports
and entertainment sectors, these relationships only
prove the brand’s trustworthiness and scale.

Shopper Professional services

Fun88 can be obtained for China and South Eastern Asian marketplaces such as Vietnam, Indonesia
and Thailand. We’re very pleased to mention which we give successful and focused customer care, obtainable 24/7 for just about any of our own customers’
problems. We give higher consideration to guarantee a
properly secured repayment method and gives private information confidentiality.

Gains Plan And Enjoyment

At Fun88, we endeavor to give the very best in on the web
gambling and professional services to offer a cutting edge and top grade encounter to your individuals.
We now have Happiness, a web-based newspaper that is
attainable even to those who find themselves not Fun88 people.
There is also Fun88 Gains plan, which supplies our members the gains
they richly are worthy of. Playing at Fun88 is not only fun and entertaining, but also very rewarding!

Fun88 could be the top gambling online provider in Asia
that gives variety of fun and exciting video gaming goods
from Sportsbook, in-participate in physical activities playing,
stay gambling, slot online games, lotto goods and more!

To give our members the modern on-line gambling
systems plus the greatest game playing encounter, Fun88 cooperates with number of
dominant gaming program which includes One particular Operates,
Microgaming and Entwine, Crown Gambling, Yellow gold
Betsoft, Deluxe, PlayTech and Laxino and Bodog.

We supply an average of ten thousand distinct Sports activities month
after month and worldwide events in Fun88’s Sportsbook,
even though an overall total of more than 100 gambling games from many different
baccarat, slots, other and roulette gambling house game titles is usually used in Fun88 Gambling house.


Getting governed and certified by trustworthy gambling body in previously promises all
people that join and play with FUN88 conforms to
specifications pair of regulatory in internet stable, safe and gambling program for your existing and upcoming members’ video games pleasure.

Fun88 also cooperates with all the world’s top system audit and security technique IOVATION,
to be sure the protection and personal privacy within your account and information privacy.


In the duration of several years in the business, Fun88 was accorded nominations
by EGR Awards structured by eGaming Assessment Newspaper the “Asian Survive Game playing Operator of year”, “Asian Owner of the Year Nominations for 2009”
and “Oriental Owner Nominations for 2010”

In 2014, Fun88 spent some time working along with Lamborghini developing Fun88 Auto racing to are competing in GT Asia
Championship. At the offer, it sponsors Fun88 Race to be competitive in Porsche Carrera Glass.

Fun88 is also seen in the MMA marketplace, partnering with
Asia’s major sporting events mass media property, One particular Championship, in 2015.

Its company ambassadors contain soccer icon Robbie Fowler and NBA
two-time MVP Steve Nash. Experiencing these kinds of massive labels in sports and entertainment sectors, these relationships only demonstrate the brand’s credibility and size.


Fun88 is accessible for China and South Eastern Oriental sells like Thailand, Indonesia and
Vietnam. We’re pleased to mention that individuals offer effective and focused support services, accessible
24/7 for virtually every of the customers’ concerns. We give substantial concern to be certain a properly secured
monthly payment strategy and give private information discretion.

Incentives PROGRAM And Leisure

Right here at Fun88, we try to give the most beneficial in on the
net video gaming and expert services to offer a technologically advanced and
top grade practical experience in our people. We have Satisfaction, a web-based publication which is certainly obtainable even going to people who find themselves
not Fun88 people. There’s also Fun88 Advantages process, that
gives our individuals the incentives they richly deserve.
Also very rewarding, even though playing at Fun88 is not only
fun and entertaining!

Leave a Reply