Ignorance of South India: A matter of shame for North Indians 

Justice Markandey Katju-

Justice Markandey Katju

Justice Markandey Katju is a former Judge, Supreme Court of India, and former Chairman, Press Council of India. The views expressed are his own.

All Indians (including South Indians) have read in their school history books of the great Mauryan Empire, the Gupta Empire, the Empire of Harshavardhan, the Mughal Empire, etc.

But how many North Indians have heard of Krishnadeva Raya of the Vijayanagar Empire (whose statue, along with his two queens, still stands in the Tirupati temple ), or of the great Chola and Pandya kings? Regrettably, very few.

Most Indians have read the Ramayana and Mahabharata, which were epics about North Indian kings, and most North Indians have read the works of Surdas, Tulsidas, Kabir, and in more recent times of the stories of Munshi Premchand, etc.

But how many North Indians have read the great Tamil epics Silappathihaaram or Manimekalai, or the great Tamil treatise Tirukkural by Tiruvalluvar ( about whom the great Tamil poet Subramania Bharati wrote ” Tamilnadu is known throughout the world because of Tirukkural ” ), the Tiruppavai by the poet-saint Andal, which is sung in the month of maarghai (maagh or January ) all over Tamilnadu, or the great poetry of Subramania Bharati who wrote powerful verses for women’s emancipation around 1910 when no Indians could even conceive of the idea? Very few.

North Indians know of Hindustani music, but how many know of Carnatic music, and its Trinity of Tyagaraj, Muthswami Dikshitar, and Shyama Shastri? Hardly any.

How many North Indians have heard of the great Keralite social reformer Narayan Guru, who belonged to the low caste Ezhava community, and fearlessly criticized and campaigned against the inhuman caste system? Practically none.

For long North Indians have regarded south India as a dark land populated by uncivilized barbarians, unaware of their great achievements in various fields. Indeed in the Ramayan, Kishkindha, which is believed to be in the present state of Karnataka, was regarded to be a land populated by monkeys, not humans, from whom Lord Rama raised a ‘vaanar sena’ ( monkey army ) to invade Sri Lanka. Many North Indians still regrettably look down on South Indians.

When I became Chief Justice of Madras High Court in 2004 in my spare time I made a deep study of South Indian ( particularly Tamilian ) history, culture, and literature, and realized that the knowledge of South Indian history, culture, and literature by North Indians was almost nil and was lamentable.

South Indian temples are massive and unbelievable unless one visits them, and they reveal the high level of knowledge of architecture and geometry of the ancient and medieval South Indians. For example, the Brihadishvara temple of Tanjore is simply astounding, and one wonders how the builders could use such huge stones in building it ( which reminds one of the Egyptian pyramids ).

The gigantic rock relief ‘Descent of the Ganges’ in the ancient port city Mahabalipuram, capital of the Pallav Empire, is truly amazing.

The large number of Roman coins found in south India show the extensive trade between south India and Ancient Rome from the time of Emperor Augustus ( who reigned from 27 B.C. to 14 A.D. ), which indicates the high development of the economy in the ancient and medieval south India.

South Indians, unlike North Indians, were sea-faring people, with extensive commercial contacts in South East Asia.

The Chola King Rajendra Chola is believed to have executed military campaigns in South East Asia ( Srilanka, Sumatra, etc ), which could only have been possible by a powerful navy.

While reading Ilango’s epic ‘Silappathiharam’ I came across these lines :

” May the Pandya King prosper, who ruled over the south, after conquering the Ganga and the Himalayas in the north ” (Silappathiharam 11: 2 : 17-22 ).

At first, I thought this was only poetic exaggeration since I had heard of North Indian kings or armies which had invaded the south, but I had never heard of a South Indian king who had invaded north India. However, I later read of credible accounts that a South Indian king ( perhaps Rajendra Chola )  had indeed led a Napoleonic invasion of north India upto the Ganges, and even beyond ( apart of invading Srilanka, the Malaya peninsula, southern Thailand, etc.).

If we want real integration of India North Indians must study the history, culture, and literature of South India too, instead of only the north, and give South Indians the proper respect they deserve.